Take three frontier mixture-of-experts models (Alibaba, OpenAI, NVIDIA; 3.6-4.0B active parameters each) and fine-tune them to reason in a low-resource language. On accuracy benchmarks almost nothing happens, and the benchmark itself is noise at this scale: changing only the random seed moves the score by 7.7 points, more than every data and recipe effect we measured. That null is our first result. The real changes live where accuracy cannot see. Base models never think in Greek: 0 of 1,000 reasoning traces, even when the question is Greek, so the model answers correctly while reasoning in a form its user cannot read, audit, or correct. After supervised fine-tuning (SFT), every released checkpoint reasons in the language of the question on ~98% of items, one family at 3x fewer tokens, with judged grammaticality improving on all four models and general ability within a few points of each base: nothing was forgotten, and fluency was gained. We propose six behavioural dimensions that make such changes measurable, each gated to reject any metric that correlates with output length, and we report how our own instruments lied: six failures, each caught by a control. What SFT cannot do is fix its own defects: a quarter of answers skip the requested format, answers leak into the reasoning channel, and an explicit "think in English" is obeyed under half the time. Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards, pre-registered before training, fixes the first two outright (fallback 24% to 2.5%, leak 3.5% to 0.0%, both against a flat random-reward control) and moves the third (+9.1pp), while the Greek reasoning habit survives an accuracy-only gradient untouched. We release five checkpoints. The instruments, the controls and the pre-registration travel to any low-resource language; Greek is the case that let us measure them.
低资源语言中的思维:SFT 构建了什么,RL 修复了什么,准确率看不到什么
AI 导读
一项研究用三个前沿混合专家模型(Alibaba、OpenAI、NVIDIA,各 3.6-4.0B 激活参数)微调其用低资源语言推理,发现准确率基准几乎无变化且本身是噪声——仅改变随机种子就能让分数波动 7.7 分,超过所有数据与配方效应。
HuggingFace Daily Papers(社区热门论文)
67
AI 编辑部评分,满分 100低资源语言中的思维:SFT 构建了什么,RL 修复了什么,准确率看不到什么
一项研究用三个前沿混合专家模型(Alibaba、OpenAI、NVIDIA,各 3.6-4.0B 激活参数)微调其用低资源语言推理,发现准确率基准几乎无变化且本身是噪声——仅改变随机种子就能让分数波动 7.7 分,超过所有数据与配方效应。
原文 · 保持原样,未翻译原文 · 未翻译
来源:HuggingFace Daily Papers(社区热门论文)· arxiv.org